Monday, February 06, 2012

Regional Foods

Savvy menu designers are quick to exploit consumer images of food on the basis of regional (multi state) and local (city or state) perceptions.  Place names like Carolina or Hawaii or Southwestern help the diner to mentally construct a vision of the fare being offered.  Well traveled and food conscious restaurant patrons are more likely than ever to draw the link between region, city or state and food.

Geographic associations take their cue from ethnic cuisines.  For most diners, Lasagna will always be linked with Italian as will Moussaka with Greek and Falafel with the Middle East.  Over time some menu items morph into mainstream American cuisine.  Most menu items, however, stay with the one who brought them to the table, the exceptions being spaghetti's ongoing migration into American and the eventual adoption or pilfering of quesadillas into Southwestern.

 

What exactly is a regional food?  

Every food writer and most consumers have a facility for connecting foods with various parts of the country.  In order to expand this knowledge base, Foodservice Research Institute used phone research to ask restaurant operators in each region of the US to list leading regional foods on their menus.  Most operators named two or three items. 

 Region 

 Leading Regional Foods

 Northeast  Lobster, meatloaf, soft shell crab, spaghetti with meat sauce, liver & onions, roast turkey dinner, eggs benedict, scrapple, home fries, blueberry pancakes, baked salmon, baked trout, crab cakes, large pancakes, belgian waffles
 South  Fried chicken, chicken fried/country fried steak, biscuits & gravy, bbq ribs, bbq pork, bbq chicken, country ham, gumbo, open faced sandwiches w/gravy, etouffee, grilled hamburgers, blackened chicken, hamburger steak plate, fried potatoes
 Central  Beef and mashed potatoes w/gravy, fish frys, pork tenderloin sandwiches, grilled pork chops, chicken fried/country fried steaks, breaded pork sandwich, chili w/ cornbread, sweet corn, farm fresh eggs, steaks
 West  Chicken fried /country fried steaks, bbq ribs, chicken fried chicken, burgers, chili, hashbrowns, quesadillas, burritos, chips and salsa, enchiladas, biscuits and gravy, pot roast, chili rellenos, green chili stew, calabazita (Mexican puerco stew), bbq burgers

 

   

Leading American Cuisines

The most richly diverse American cuisine is American-Traditional.  Menu items in this group can be found in all regions of the country.  The second most popular regional cuisine is Southern with its heavy emphasis on chicken and fried foods, biscuits & gravy, catfish and ham.  Closely associated with Southern is American-Spicy, which includes barbecue and hot selections such as buffalo wings and chili.  Each regional cuisine draws on a particular set of sauces, cooking styles and seasonings.  Using the MenuMine database of chain menus, over 30,000 menu items are classified by individual American and Ethnic cuisines.  American cuisines along with leading items are shown in the table below.
 

 Cuisine

 Menu Items

 American Traditional
 Hamburgers, cheeseburgers, sirloin steak dinner, pancakes, fries, omelets, baked potato, bacon cheeseburger, meatloaf, pot roast, mashed potatoes, pork chops, mac and cheese, tuna salad sandwich, grilled cheese sandwich, hot dog, roasted/baked chicken, ribeye steak, roast turkey dinner, chicken pot pie, garden salad, turkey breast sandwich, philly cheesesteak, ham and cheese sandwich, steak sandwich, prime rib dinner, hot turkey sandwich, chicken noodle soup, liver and onions 
 Southern  Fried chicken, chicken strips/tenders, chicken fried/country fried steak, catfish, fried chicken salad, ham steak dinner, popcorn shrimp, fried okra, red beans and rice, poor-boy sandwich, biscuits & gravy
 Cajun/Creole  Blackened chicken breast dinner, jambalya, cajun chicken sandwich, seafood gumbo, cajun shrimp & pasta, cajun chicken pasta, blackened chicken salad
 American-Seaboard  Lobster, crab cakes, fried shrimp dinner, clam chowder, fried fish sandwich, clam strips, broiled cod, oysters, seafood platter, shrimp cocktail
 Southwestern  Chili, stuffed jalapano,southwest chicken salad, monterey/santa fe chicken breast sandwich, chips & salsa, chicken quesadilla, veggie quesadilla
 Western  Potato skins w/ bacon and cheese, sirloin steak dinner, breakfast skillets, ribeye steaks, pepper steak, grilled trout
 American-Spicy  Baby back ribs, buffalo wings, bbq pork sandwich, hickory smoked chicken, chili dog, chili cheese fries, buffalo chicken salad
 California/Pacific  Veggie pizza, cobb salad, veggie burger, turkey burger, turkey avocado sandwich, wrap sandwich, tuna melt sandwich
 

 

Leading Cities and States 

State and City names are mentioned on 3% of all items on chain menus.  Whether the reference is to Hawaiian Pizza or a Chicago Hot Dog or to Wisconsin Cheese Soup or Maine Lobster, a geographic connection builds on the folklore of places influencing the purchasing decision.

New York has captured a huge share of city mentions on menus mainly because of New York Strip Steaks and NY Pizza.  Texas comes in second followed by California.  Just about every state is mentioned in the MenuMine database of chain menus.  The task at hand for those responsible for menu content and promotion is to be certain that the cache of a particular state is strong in all parts of the country (if a national chain) or fairly well known in your locality.  Naturally, a little consumer research will pay dividends.

 Leading Cities and States (basis 1095 menu items with state/city in name)

 New York 24%  Florida 3%  Tennessee <1%
 Texas 11%  Louisiana 3%  Mississippi <1%
 California 10%  Denver 3%  Memphis <1%
 Hawaii 8%  Wisconsin 3%  San Francisco <1%
 Maine 7%  Idaho 2%  Virginia <1%
 Alaska 6%  Colorado 2%  Kansas City <1%
 Chicago 4%  Carolina 1%  Kentucky <1%
 New Orleans 3%  St. Louis 1%  Georgia <1%
 Boston 3%  Sante Fe 1%  Others

  

Leading American Cuisines

The most richly diverse American cuisine is American-Traditional.  Menu items in this group can be found in all regions of the country.  The second most popular regional cuisine is Southern with its heavy emphasis on chicken and fried foods, biscuits & gravy, catfish and ham.  Closely associated with Southern is American-Spicy, which includes barbecue and hot selections such as buffalo wings and chili.  Each regional cuisine draws on a particular set of sauces, cooking styles and seasonings.  Using the MenuMine database of chain menus, over 30,000 menu items are classified by individual American and Ethnic cuisines.  American cuisines along with leading items are shown in the table below.
 

 Cuisine

 Menu Items

 American Traditional
 Hamburgers, cheeseburgers, sirloin steak dinner, pancakes, fries, omelets, baked potato, bacon cheeseburger, meatloaf, pot roast, mashed potatoes, pork chops, mac and cheese, tuna salad sandwich, grilled cheese sandwich, hot dog, roasted/baked chicken, ribeye steak, roast turkey dinner, chicken pot pie, garden salad, turkey breast sandwich, philly cheesesteak, ham and cheese sandwich, steak sandwich, prime rib dinner, hot turkey sandwich, chicken noodle soup, liver and onions 
 Southern  Fried chicken, chicken strips/tenders, chicken fried/country fried steak, catfish, fried chicken salad, ham steak dinner, popcorn shrimp, fried okra, red beans and rice, poor-boy sandwich, biscuits & gravy
 Cajun/Creole  Blackened chicken breast dinner, jambalya, cajun chicken sandwich, seafood gumbo, cajun shrimp & pasta, cajun chicken pasta, blackened chicken salad
 American-Seaboard  Lobster, crab cakes, fried shrimp dinner, clam chowder, fried fish sandwich, clam strips, broiled cod, oysters, seafood platter, shrimp cocktail
 Southwestern  Chili, stuffed jalapano,southwest chicken salad, monterey/santa fe chicken breast sandwich, chips & salsa, chicken quesadilla, veggie quesadilla
 Western  Potato skins w/ bacon and cheese, sirloin steak dinner, breakfast skillets, ribeye steaks, pepper steak, grilled trout
 American-Spicy  Baby back ribs, buffalo wings, bbq pork sandwich, hickory smoked chicken, chili dog, chili cheese fries, buffalo chicken salad
 California/Pacific  Veggie pizza, cobb salad, veggie burger, turkey burger, turkey avocado sandwich, wrap sandwich, tuna melt sandwich

  

Regional and Local Menu Items

When determining the name of a menu item, operators are advised to observe seven essential menu design guidelines.  Somewhat similar to the "four P's" of packaged goods marketing, the "seven P's" are:

 - Protein --- is it beef, chicken, seafood or pork, or no protein?

 - Position on Menu --- is it an appetizer, sandwich, soup, salad or entree?

 - Price --- what does it cost and (how much do I get)?

 - Promotion --- what are the reasons why I should order the item?

 - Place --- what are the cuisine and image associations which further describe the menu item?

Note: place is often implied by the restaurant concept or the item name

 - Preparation --- is the item grilled, pan fried or deep fried or served chilled?

 - Profile of Flavors --- sauces, seasonings, cheeses, breads, batters, sides, dressing, stuffing/filling or other flavor enhancer used

All "7 P's" are essential to painting a complete picture of the food being offered.

 State and City Related Menu Items  (selected from 1095 menu items with state/city in name) 

 Carolina Chicken Salad --- Ruby Tuesday  Florida Snapper --- Shula's Steak House
 Mississippi Fried Catfish --- Dave & Busters  Georgia Chopped Pork ---Fox & Hounds
 New York Style Pizza --- Sbarro  Louisiana Jambalaya --- Marie Callender's
 Hawaiian Pizza --- Donato's Pizza  Chicago Dog --- Orange Julius
 Texas Burger --- Houston's  St. Louis Ribs --- Buffalo's Southwest Cafe
 Maine Lobster Dim Sum ---Roy's  Wisconsin Fried Cheese --- Joe's Crab Shack
 Bone-In Kansas City Strip --- Sullivan's Steakhouse  California Burger --- Daily Grill
 Colorado Prime Rib --- Durango Steak House  Boston Clam Chowder --- Anthony's Pier 4
 Idaho Beef Tenderloin --- Trotter's To Go  Denver Omelet --- Ruby's Diner
 Boston Cream Pie --- Baker's Square  Filet of Alaskan Cod --- Perko's Cafe
 Shrimp New Orleans --- Bubba Gump Shrimp  New Orleans Jambalaya --- Houlihan's
 Wisconsin Rainbow Trout --- McCormick & Schmick's  Mississippi Mudd Pie --- Po Folks
 New York Strip Steak ---Perkins Rest. & Bakery  Grilled Hawaiian Salad --- Cheddar's
 San Francisco Crab Cake --- Nieman Marcus  St. Louis Burger --- Johnny Rocket's
 Sante Fe Mini Chimis --- American Cafe  Memphis Fries --- Red, Hot & Blue
 Virginia Ham w/Raisin Sce. --- New Hampshire Univ.  Georgia Peach Smoothie --- World Wrapps
 Prime New York Steak --- Maggiano's Little Italy  Wisconsin Cheese Soup --- Atlanta Bread Co.
 Salad of Maine Lobster --- Oceana  Homestyle Texas Chili --- Iron Skillet

 

Locally Grown Fruits and Vegetables

Survey research conducted with restaurant operators by Foodservice Research Institute reveals that the leading locally grown produce used to prepare seasonal menu items are strawberries and pumpkins/squash.  Unlike tree fruits such as apples and citrus and vine fruits such as grapes, and tubers like potatoes, strawberries and pumpkin/squash are grown in just about all states.  One third of operators interviewed mention they use locally grown strawberries to prepare seasonal pies and shortcake.  Twenty percent mention pumpkin and squash, 20% fruit plates and fruit pies, 15% peppers for stews and chili.  Other produce mentioned include canteloupe and watermelon, sweet corn, green beans, okra, green tomatoes and sweet potatoes. 

                                                                                                                                      

Newsletter Signup



Menu Intelligence

Gain perspective into your product categories' performance on the menu with Menu Intelligence Reports

MenuIntelligenceReportSampleThumb

MenuMine Trend

  • Protein Positioning on the Menu by Entree and Item Type Chicken and Beef are the largest volume proteins, as well as the most frequently menued on American restaurant menus. Individually, Beef and Chicken are each listed on approximately one of every four entrees, whether Center of the Plate (COP) or Prepared Entrees (PE).
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8

Login Form